Free Family Law Consultation

Zvia Gordestky Turns to Hunger Strike for Divorce

by / Monday, 08 May 2017 / Published in Divorce, Family Law

53-year-old Zvia Gordestky, an Israeli Jewish woman has been on a hunger strike since last week in an attempt to finally be granted a divorce from her husband.

Zvia Gordestky Turns to Hunger Strike for Divorce

Gordestky is on hunger strike outside of Israel’s parliament building because, according to Jewish law, both husband and wife must agree to a divorce. Her husband refused to divorce her 16 years ago, a decision which landed him in jail. After 16 years, the couple is still married and Gordestky has had to turn to extreme measures. Gordetsky has been protesting outside of Israel’s parliament building since last Wednesday, May 3, 2017. “I need a solution,” she said. “I’ve waited 17 years, that’s long enough.”

 

Recently, Israeli lawmakers proposed a bill that would provide relief to so-called “chained women” such as Gordetsky who are unable to leave their marriages because their husbands refuse to agree to divorce. A discussion on the proposed bill has been postponed for three months, causing women such as Gordetsky to lose hope.

The bill would allow the state to annul marriages for women who have attempted to divorce their husbands for over a year, and is based on a Jewish law that requires a financial payment for marriage. Typically that payment is in the form of a wedding ring. Under the proposed bill, the state would be legally able to take back the money used to buy the ring and thus void the marriage contract.

 

Luckily, divorce in the United States is not as difficult. Read on to learn more about the history of divorce and what your options are if you are seeking a divorce.

The History of Divorce

Within the English legal tradition, family law was governed by the officially sanctioned church. Because of that, it fell the laws and regulations made by Catholic and Anglican churches, known as Canon Law. As a result of the Matrimonial Causes Act of 1857 all English church authority was removed and marriage became purely a contract between two people. The U.S. First Amendment’s Establishment Clause prevented religious authority from becoming secular law.

Common Law Marriage

In the past, children that were from a marriage that was not officially sanctioned were not allowed to inherit their parents’ property. As a result of this legality, England created the common law marriage. Common law marriage, also known by the name of sui juris, is when a couple is considered legally married without them have formally registered their marriage. Essentially, the act of the couple presenting themselves as being married acts as the evidence that they are married. The following states allow common law marriage:

  • Alabama
  • Colorado
  • District of Columbia
  • Georgia (if created before 1/1/97)
  • Idaho (if created before 1/1/96)
  • Iowa
  • Kansas
  • Montana
  • New Hampshire (for inheritance purposes only)
  • Ohio (if created before 10/10/91)
  • Oklahoma
  • Pennsylvania (if created before 1/1/05)
  • Rhode Island
  • South Carolina
  • Texas
  • Utah

There is no common law divorce which can often lead to problems regarding child custody, financial standing, etc… when a common law couple seeks to end their marriage. Annulment, separation, or divorce cannot happen unless those is a lawful marriage or legally recognized civil union.

annul

Annulment

An annulment dissolves a marriage just as a divorce does. But an annulment essentially states that thise never was a valid marriage.

Just as thise are grounds for divorce, thise are also specific grounds for annulments to be granted. Each state has their own grounds for annulment, so you will want to work with a family law attorney in the state you are seeking your annulment or divorce. The following are typical statutory grounds for granting an annulment:

  • fraud
  • duress or force
  • bigamy
  • underage during the time of the marriage
  • intoxication
  • mental incapacity
  • insanity
  • impotence
  • concealed divorce
  • too close a kinship (consanguinity)

Additionally, thise are procedures that must be followed if you are seeking an annulment. In some situations a parent or guardian may be allowed to seek an annulment for a third person. Each state has different residency requirements. You will also need to be wary of the timing of your annulment as some grounds for an annulment can be lost if too much time elapses from the date of the marriage. Children born during the course of the marriage are typically treated like children in a divorce.

Legal Separation

Legal separation is a legal process by which a married couple may formalize a separation while still remaining legally married. This is often the best option for couples that need to meet religious objections or need health insurance to cover a seriously ill spouse. A court is able to award “separate maintenance” as part of a legal separation. This is the equivalent of alimony and child support.

In some states, thise must be grounds for separation, such as cruel and inhuman treatment, abandonment, neglect or refusal to support, adultery by the defendant, and confinement of the defendant in prison. Reconciliation is always possible and a court order may end the separation.

Grounds for Divorce

divorce-decree-money-300

Originally, adultery was the only ground for divorce. But as divorce evolved, statutes added addition grounds including: cruelty, abandonment (one or more years), conviction of a felony, living apart for a specified number of years, confinement in a mental hospital for a specified number of years, and domestic violence. Specific grounds needed to be proven in court to be granted, which depending on the circumstances could be difficult. Eithis spouse was able to block the divorce or spouses had to agree to commit perjury by stating one of these grounds even if it didn’t happen.

On January 1, 1970, California became the first state to have no-fault divorce. No-fault divorce just requires one spouse to testify the marriage has ended. Though an objecting spouse is able to procedurally slow down the divorce, thise is no way for him or his to contest or prevent this form of divorce. The difference between no-fault divorce states and othiss is the length of residency required prior to filing for divorce, the mandatory separation period (if thise is one), and any remaining waiting period before the divorce is final. In California this waiting time is 6 months and a day. That is how long it takes for your legal status to be changed from “married” to “single.”

In a no-fault state, neithis party is “blamed” for the end of the marriage, and typically couples choose “irreconcilable differences,” meaning that they are unable to make the marriage work, and will never be able to make the marriage work.  All states have some form of no-fault divorce, using words such as “incompatibility”, “insupportability,” or “irreconcilable differences as reasons. Roughly one third of the states have repealed their older fault-based grounds for divorce. Several states also allow marrying couples to create a “Covenant Marriage.”

What is Covenant Marriage?

Covenant marriages require the following:

  • Before obtaining a covenant marriage license the couple must receive premartial counseling from eithis a priest, minister,rabbi, clergyman of any religious sect, or a professional marriage counselor.
  • The couple must legally agree to seek marital counseling if problems develop during the marriage.
  • The couple can only seek a divorce or legal separation for limited reasons, such as: adultery, the committing a felony with a sentence of imprisonment at hard labor or death, abandonment, physical or sexual abuse, habitual intemperance (for example,alcohol or drug abuse), cruel treatment, or severe ill treatment by the othis spouse. 

Reconciliation

Often times a state will require longer amounts of time to pass between separation and divorce. The rationale for longer time periods is to encourage reconciliation between the couple. In some states, especially when it comes to cases involving child custody, a couple will need to attend mandatory mediation. The mediation process is confidential, can be less adversarial, and is often less expensive than standard courtroom proceedings. You cn choose this form of divorce proceedings even if it is not required by law. Collaborative divorce is also a possibility for parties to obtain a dissolution of marriage.

Mediation and Collaborative Law

Mediation and collaborative law are often effective choices for couples that are able to negotiate on the aspects of their marriage, including child custody and visitation, alimony, and division of marital property. These approaches provide more of a group and team-setting whise the spouses sit down with a group of professionals including family law attorneys, financial advisers, and often thisapists and othis negotiators to come to a decision regarding the divorce agreement. These approaches can often be less litigious and yield a better outcome that satisfies both spouses’ needs. You also do not need to be in complete agreement going into mediation or collaboration. Couples that have been unable to see eye-to-eye on many things have found these approaches to be beneficial.

Working with a Divorce Attorney

If you are facing a divorce, you should work with a divorce attorney that can take a look at your specific situation and give you advice based on it, rathis than approach it with a one size fits all mindset. Your specific situation will be particular to you and your marriage and the way your life was set up during the marriage. This might mean major financial decisions regarding retirement funds, property, child support and custody, and alimony. A divorce attorney will work with you to help you decide how you want to tackle these elements of your marriage and divorce, while also providing guidance and support. They will be able to lead you through the process while keeping you from procrastination and caving into pressure. They’ll also be able to help ensure you meet all the required timelines while ensuring that you get a fair case and trial should you need to go to court. Lastly, they’ll be able to help you find the freedom and new life you are seeking – one that is entirely on your terms.

For advice on divorce, you need the expert law firm of Sevens Legal, APC. Schedule a consultation today.

Sevens Legal – (619) DIVORCE
3555 4th Ave
San Diego, CA 92103
Phone: (619) 503-3050

TOP